The ambiguity surrounding a painting belonged to Central Lutheran Church intensified of late when a Winona Post reader noticed that the actual painting pictured with the unique story looked very familiar. Really, Arlene Prosen said, it appears just like a painting that hangs in the church of her childhood in Hayfield, Minnesota. Prosen stated she bound for the photo to a friend that as well attended the Trinity Lutheran Church in Hayfield and the pair agrees: Its the same.

The original Winona Post story detailed the reinstatement work of home artist John Durfey on a seven-foot-tall oil painting, which had been in storage at Central Lutheran Church. The painting features a renaissance scene with an archangel and several women at Christas tomb and despite the fact that it is signed in pencil on the back by somebody named Orvin Olson, not much else is recognized about the origin of the art.